In the world of music and journalism, Jann Wenner stands as a towering figure. As the founder of Rolling Stone and a co-founder of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, his contributions have left an indelible mark. However, recent comments made by Wenner have ignited a storm of controversy, raising important questions about diversity and inclusion in the music industry.
Wenner’s statements, published in a New York Times interview, have drawn criticism for their disparaging nature. In the interview, Wenner explained why he had chosen to feature only white rock performers in his book, labeling them the “philosophers of rock.” These comments led to a unanimous vote by the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame board to remove Wenner from his position.
“The Masters,” Wenner’s book, featured interviews with legendary musicians such as Bono, Bob Dylan, Jerry Garcia, Mick Jagger, John Lennon, Bruce Springsteen, and Pete Townshend—all of whom are white males. Wenner justified his choices by claiming that the women he interviewed were not “articulate enough on this intellectual level,” and he argued that Black artists of the time were not “in the zeitgeist.”
Recognizing the gravity of his remarks, Wenner issued a series of apologies over the weekend, including an official statement through his publisher, Little, Brown and Company. In his statement, Wenner expressed deep remorse, saying, “I apologize wholeheartedly for those remarks.” He emphasized that his choice of interviews did not reflect his genuine appreciation for the multitude of influential artists he respected. He pledged to celebrate and promote these artists and their music throughout his life, acknowledging the inflammatory nature of his poorly chosen words.
However, the fallout from his comments extended beyond apologies. In addition to losing his position on the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame board, Wenner faced further consequences when his scheduled appearance at New Jersey’s Montclair literary festival later in the month was canceled.
Wenner’s legacy in the music industry is substantial. He founded Rolling Stone in 1967 and played a pivotal role in shaping its editorial direction until 2019. His contributions earned him induction into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame as a non-performer in 2004, a recognition stemming from his involvement in its inception in 1983.
Nevertheless, the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame faced criticism for being exclusive, often favoring musicians who met a specific white rock criterion. This perception challenged the inclusive and revolutionary spirit of rock ‘n’ roll. The organization’s current chairman, John Sykes, has made efforts to address this issue, emphasizing that rock ‘n’ roll encompasses a diverse range of sounds, including R&B, gospel, and country.
Recent inductions into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame reflect a more inclusive approach, with artists like Missy Elliott, the Spinners, Willie Nelson, and Rage Against the Machine being recognized. Sykes noted that the percentage of female inductees had risen from 14-15% to nearly 25% in the last five years. This evolution represents a positive shift in both sound and genre within the inductees’ class.
Despite these positive developments, Wenner’s comments have left a stain on his legacy. Criticism from figures like Joe Hagan, the author of the critical but authorized biography “Sticky Fingers,” and feminist critic Ellen Willis, who refused to write for Rolling Stone, highlights the damaging impact of Wenner’s words. Willis, in 1970, accused Rolling Stone of perpetuating a culture that referred to women as “chicks” and treated them as interchangeable objects, reinforcing the oppression of women.
In his interview with the New York Times, Wenner appeared to acknowledge the potential backlash he would face, even contemplating the inclusion of Black and female artists who didn’t meet the same historical standards, simply for public relations purposes.
As the music industry continues to evolve and strive for inclusivity, Jann Wenner’s comments serve as a stark reminder of the importance of recognizing and celebrating the contributions of artists from all backgrounds. His remarks have sparked a necessary conversation about diversity and representation within the industry, prompting a reevaluation of its history and future direction.
Image Source: Google
